G.R. NO. 147791 - CONSTRUCTION DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION OF THE PHILIPPINES, VS. REBECCA G. ESTRELLA, RACHEL E. FLETCHER, PHILIPPINE PHOENIX SURETY & INSURANCE INC., BATANGAS LAGUNA TAYABAS BUS CO., AND WILFREDO DATINGUINOOD E C I S I O N - Supreme Court E-Library

Ruling

WHEREFORE, judgment is rendered: In the Complaint - 1. In favor of the plaintiffs and against the defendants BLTB, Wilfredo Datinguinoo, Construction and Development Corporation of the Philippines (now PNCC) and Espiridion Payunan, Jr., ordering said defendants, jointly and severally to pay the plaintiffs the sum of P79,254.43 as actual damages and to pay the sum of P10,000.00 as attorney's fees or a total of P89,254.43; 2. In addition, defendant Construction and Development Corporation of the Philippines and defendant Espiridion Payunan, Jr., shall pay the plaintiffs the amount of Fifty Thousand (P50,000.00) Pesos to plaintiff Rachel Fletcher and Twenty Five Thousand (P25,000.00) Pesos to plaintiff Rebecca Estrella; 3. On the counterclaim of BLTB Co. and Wilfredo Datinguinoo - Dismissing the counterclaim; 4. On the crossclaim against Construction and Development Corporation of the Philippines (now PNCC) and Espiridion Payunan, Jr. - Dismissing the crossclaim; 5. On the counterclaim of Construction and Development Corporation of the Philippines (now PNCC) - Dismissing the counterclaim; 6. On the crossclaim against BLTB - Dismissing the crossclaim; 7. On the Third Party Complaint by Construction and Development Corporation of the Philippines against Philippine Phoenix Surety and Insurance, Incorporated - Dismissing the Third Party Complaint. SO ORDERED.