G.R. No. 208595 -

Ruling

WHEREFORE, premises considered, judgment is hereby rendered in this case in favor of the plaintiffs and against the defendants, as follows: Declaring Transfer Certificate of Title Nos. T-34992, T-34993, T-34994, T-34995, T-34996, null and void ab initio, or inexistent, and hereby ordering the cancellation of said titles; Ordering the revival or restoration of Original Certificate of Title No. RP-837 (3107) in the name of Bawing Ipo married to Tanod (Subano); Ordering the PARTITION of the property covered by the said original Certificate [of] Title No. RP-837 (3107) in SEVEN (7) equal shares among ONDAY BAWING, IGBAY BAWING, GARAY BAWING, ANONG BAWING, OCTOC BAWING, MARTINA BAWING AND PEDRO BAWING and/or their respective heirs, and to conduct a subdivision survey thereon in accordance with said partition, nullifying hereto the previous subdivision survey conducted on said property; Ordering the defendants to render an accounting of the products and/or income of the properties which were covered by titles under the names of BENIGNO ISAW, as Transfer Certificate of Title Nos. T-34992 and T-34994, which are among those declared null and void hereon and to deduct there from the corresponding amount allegedly paid to spouses David Barrios and Luz Lucasan Barrios and also the amount allegedly paid to Fausto Isaw in the total sum of Three Thousand Pesos (P3,000.00)' Ordering the defendants to pay plaintiffs the amount of Thirty Thousand Pesos (P30,000.00) as Attorney's Fees and the amount of Twenty Thousand Pesos (P20,000.00) for ligations expenses. Counterclaim is DISMISSED for lack of merit. No special pronouncement as to cost. Let copies of this decision be furnished to the Registry of Deeds of Zamboanga del Norte for implementation. SO ORDERED.