G.R. NO. 166594 -

Ruling

WHEREFORE, the respondents are hereby ordered to reinstate the complainants to their former positions with backwages from the date their salaries were withheld until they are actually reinstated. Further, the respondents are ordered to pay the complainants their service incentive leave pay and 13 th month pay as follows: 1) BOBBY AGLIONES a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 2) RONALD ARGON a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 3) LORENZO BABAS a) Backwages - P84,943.09 b) 13 th month pay - 3,788.29 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 669.67 4) ANTONIO BALAJADIA a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 5) FELIPE BINGHAY, JR. a) Backwages - P77,752.16 b) 13 th month pay - 3,187.50 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 612.97 6) ROGELIO BUATES a) Backwages - P94,649.88 b) 13 th month pay - 3,880.23 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 746.19 7) ANTONIO BULI a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 8) SANDRO BUSTAMANTE a) Backwages - P77,752.16 b) 13 th month pay - 3,187.50 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 612.97 9) DANILO CARDENAS a) Backwages - P83,782.62 b) 13 th month pay - 3,434.72 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 660.51 10) EDILBERTO CORDOVA a) Backwages - P77,752.16 b) 13 th month pay - 3,187.50 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 612.97 11) SAMUEL DALMACIO a) Backwages - P80,906.82 b) 13 th month pay - 3,316.82 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 637.83 12) ALVARO DELA CRUZ a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 13) ARCILO DELGADO a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 14) MARIO GALSIM a) Backwages - P84,943.09 b) 13 th month pay - 3,788.29 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 669.67 15) JOSHUA GARCIA a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 16) GLORIOSO LLANETA a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 17) ARNULFO LORENZO a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 18) LEODIGARIO LUBIANO, JR. a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 19) BESINIDO MAGBANUA a) Backwages - P77,752.16 b) 13 th month pay - 3,187.50 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 612.97 20) MAXIMO MAGHANOY a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 21) EDGARDO MONCADO a) Backwages - P77,752.16 b) 13 th month pay - 3,187.50 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 612.97 22) ROGELIO RIVERA a) Backwages - P78,831.98 b) 13 th month pay - 3,231.76 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 621.47 23) RICHARD ROMOROSA a) Backwages - P77,752.16 b) 13 th month pay - 3,187.50 c) Service Incentive Leave pay - 612.97 24) ENRIQUE