TL;DR — Ruling
WHEREFORE , in view of all the foregoing, the Court resolved to render judgment as follows: 1. Order the closure of the water refilling stations located at Pasay Road Extension, Makati City (AV-Arnaiz) and No. 8788 Doña Aguirre Avenue cor. Daisy Road, Pilar Villas, Las Piñas (AV-Pilar) operated by defendant Makati Water, Inc.
WHEREFORE , in view of all the foregoing, the Court resolved to render judgment as follows: 1. Order the closure of the water refilling stations located at Pasay Road Extension, Makati City (AV-Arnaiz) and No. 8788 Doña Aguirre Avenue cor. Daisy Road, Pilar Villas, Las Piñas (AV-Pilar) operated by defendant Makati Water, Inc.; 2. Order the defendant to pay the plaintiff compensatory damages in the amount of P351,911.10 for Civil Case No. 6919[2] and P233,979.60 for Civil Case No. 6919[1]; 3. Order the defendant to pay exemplary damages amounting to One Hundred Thousand (Php 100,000.00) Pesos; 4. Order defendant to pay 25% of the total amount due for the two (2) cases as and for attorney's fees; 5. Costs of suit. As to the prayer of the defendant for compulsory counterclaim, the Court finds that no sufficient injury was caused to the defendant by the filing of the Complaint, hence, no sufficient basis to grant it. SO ORDERED.