G.R. No. 115788 - SPS. SONYA & ISMAEL MATHAY, JR., VS. HON. COURT OF APPEALS, SPS. TEODULFO & SYLVIA ATANGAN, SPS. AGUSTINA & AMOR POBLETE, SPS. EDUARDO & FELICISIMA TIRONA.

Ruling

WHEREFORE, foregoing considered, (sic) judgment is hereby rendered in favor of the defendants: a) declaring Contract of Sale 3397 in favor of Tomas Lucido, the Assignment of Sale Certificate No. 3397 issued by Tomas Lucido in favor of Onofre Batallones and Norberto Quimio, the Deed of Conveyance in favor of Onofre Batallones and Norberto Quimio and Transfer Certificate of Title No. 85866 in the name of Onofre Batallones and Norberto Quimio, as null and void; b) declaring Transfer Certificates of Title No. T-195350, T-195351, T-192527, T-192529, T192528, T-192532, T-252996, T-252997, T-252998, T-252999, T-253000, T-253001, T-253002, T-253003, T-253004, T-253005, T-253037, T-206078, T-203724, T-220506, T-220607, T-220608, T-220605, T-203728, T-203726, T-203730, T-203723 and T-203725, as null and void, and directing the Register of Deeds of Cavite Province to cancel them; c) ordering Spouses Teodulfo Atangan & Sylvia Atangan, Onofre Batallones, Norerto (sic) Quimio, Spouses Tomas Lucido and Juana Batallones, Agustin Poblete, Juancho Albert Poblete, Spouses Bonifacio Motas and Juliana Motas, Soledad Mateo, Ricardo Malabanan, Flocerfina Bartolome, Spouses Eugenio Bartolome and Ruperto Bartolome, Spouses Eduardo Tirona and Felicisima Tirona and Anania Gervania (sic) to surrender to the Office of the Register of Deeds of Cavite their owners copy of their Transfer of Certificates of Title covering portions of Lot 2186; d) declaring TCT No. T-11304 [sic][7] valid and the defendants to have superior rights to the property in question and to be the true and lawful owners of the same; e) ordering plaintiffs jointly and severally liable to pay defendants attorneys fees of P50,000.00 and to pay the costs; f) denying all other claims of the parties for lack of basis in law and/or evidence. SO ORDERED.